"We place the reconstruction focused on smart and irreversible."
Thus, the RP of 14 cited July 2010 - the day of the election of women to power red-green prime minister of North Rhine-Westphalia - the future education minister Sylvia Löhr.
And she means the school and education in NRW. The goal: the comprehensive school.
against the adverbs "smart" and "targeted" is you have no objections to policy proposals, first anything - on the contrary: The more often you wish. But "irreversible"?
not we living in an enlightened age in which we have recognized the constant change as the principle by which alone the goal of continuous improvement be achieved?
Since cement so someone wants to make something socially irreversible.
reminds in an unpleasant way to people who were sure to have recognized the truth for themselves and therefore derives the authority to bless all the other so that the long term. Nor did Fidel Castro Cuba be revolutionized designed? In any case, it is the staunch ideologues who keep their image in the world for the real thing.
. "As ordered" So the RP commented a few weeks - the time of the coalition negotiations - some of the red-green project, ordered by the voters ... not to be ignored: the irony in this formulation.
The comprehensive school, 'as ordered?
Well, some certainly, finally, neither the SPD nor the Greens in their election programs that aim at presenting essential point.
were, but since not many other electoral motives?
We have the black and yellow a receipt policy in the federal government for its policy of letzten Monate geben...
Wir müssen ein Signal setzen gegen den Krieg in Afghanistan, gegen die Energiepolitik, die es möglich macht, dass das Öl das Meer verseucht, gegen die Finanzkrise im allgemeinen, gegen die Hilfen für Griechenland im Besonderen, gegen die ungerechten Mehrwertsteuervergünstigungen für Hotels, gegen … gegen... gegen...
Wir müssen dem Westerwelle eins auswischen wegen … wir müssen der Merkel eins auswischen wegen …
Aber es ist doch Landtagswahl und nicht Bundestagswahl!
Ach so, ja, dann müssen wir dem Rüttgers eins auswischen, erstens allgemein und zweitens .. war da nicht die Behauptung eines kleinen Skandals? … Und dann sind da ja even these fees ... It's high time the other times to give another chance!
that a few months earlier, still great satisfaction in the land of the black-yellow coalition seemed to bring a good majority, who take care?
Oh, and then there was also the seductive and innocent and oh so social and just sounding little sentence: "Longer learn together."
What designates a dangerous mistake of which I have proven time and again (and conclusively proven and justified), as in the previous blog.
good that it is now clear what is meant: the comprehensive school - "irreversible". And now even more clearly, what mean in this context "wise" and "targeted": Smooth, but tactically sized steps and with a shift of responsibility in decentralized decision-making bodies such as municipalities. `Longer
learn together ', which presumably many voters have" ordered "really. Whether you know that numerous studies show (also around PISA!), How to work successfully, most forms of structured school education? Whether you know how successfully cut the federal states, all dedicated to the improvement of the differentiated school system prescribed and not its abolition, and have performed poorly as the others? Whether you know, that well-known experts who flirted with complete systems that give now quite clear that school structural changes should have no demonstrable success increases. A coyly worded, there is at least no deterioration ...
know whether that would be touched upon closer inspection, much of what one expects from change to the comprehensive school, actually in the field of family and social policy? Whether
know that have spoken out after a recent Forsa poll of citizens in NRW already 57% against an extension of primary schooling by two years and 76% against the closure of secondary schools and high schools in favor of a single school?
SPIEGEL deals in the edition of 05.07.2010 in its cover story with the Bildungskleinstaaterei in Germany ("An abyss of federalism") and complained vehemently Reformwut all states in terms of school education: "The citizens are locked up in the Labyrinth of Germany's 16 school systems. "" Educational policy is seen every school structural reform of money. "
And yet one is in North Rhine-Westphalia on now is to build ideological.
woman power could still send her son to a grammar school, Löhr woman has no children.
But soon there will be many people who rub their eyes when it becomes clear that applications to the success of models Secondary schools and colleges in North Rhine-Westphalia will not be able to give. And say the reformers, we find, however, such principles of education in the interior of unity schools
again ... And I'm sure it will - start a school fight - most recently in Hamburg.
And I'm sure that will claim many of the bills and lesson voters that they had not "ordered".
lot of power will it all cost. Too much money. And time.
But if it leads to that one finally realizes that schools only get better if the content and improve the competence of the teachers - to the teacher-student ratios and the forms of conveyance - then has perhaps at the end but worth the effort.
Oh yes, still, I attach importance to the statement that I have set before the election: The above
school policy, I will not order `', and I have not ordered.
And the school fight? Well, you have gained experience in the successful engagement with radical unity school reforms that were called mal "development planning", sometimes "co-op school," time "coverage (!) Comprehensive school" ...
see if the 'Irreversible', this time can impose.
Wolfgang clip in July 2010
0 comments:
Post a Comment